Every number on this page is computed by the Chapter 1 notebook's own code (the fan uses Worked Example 8.1's 100,000 paths on the book's random seed 8). Your notes stay on this page until you leave it; copy the memo before you go.
Meridian's board meets in three weeks to choose among the digital pivot, the restructuring, and the turnaround. You are on the corporate strategy team. The CFO wants a single scorecard; the head of Digital Solutions wants the board to see the full picture. Your job is to show the board what one number reveals and what it hides.
Use AXIOM to see Meridian as a state, compare the three options as paths, and test whether any single score can rank them.
Meridian today: Table 3.1. The three options move four of the eight readings in the Chapter 1 model (Worked Example 1.1); the other four are held at today's values.
Open the state inspector and the radar view. For each of the eight readings, note what it measures and where the data would come from in a real company. Which two readings would be hardest to measure reliably, and why?
Units and offices: Tables 3.1 and 5.2. Scaled error: the error band divided by the reading's declared scale (Chapter 3), so the eight can be compared.
Each spoke is a reading on Chapter 3's declared scale: indices over 100, the four unbounded readings over today's value. The shaded ring is each reading's error band.
The widest error bands, once scaled, belong to strategic risk (±6 points from the risk committee, 0.060) and workforce capability (±5 from the skills survey, 0.050). Both rest on judgment or surveys rather than accounts, which is why they are the hardest to measure reliably. Liquidity, from treasury systems, is the most precise (0.010).
Table 5.2; notebook cell 4.
Use the trajectory player to run each option over five years. Pause around month 21 and at the sale date in Year 1. Record liquidity, technology platform, efficiency, and strategic risk at Year 5 for each option.
Paths: the Chapter 1 model, Eq. 1.B.1 with Table 1.B.1, month by month (Online Appendix 1.B). Liquidity is an index, today = 100 = $620 million, so a point is $6.2 million. The score is the CFO's: a quarter on each of liquidity, technology and efficiency, less a quarter of strategic risk.
At month 21 the digital option's liquidity is near its low and its score is the lowest of the three. At month 12 the restructuring's liquidity jumps when the sale closes.
Table 1.9; notebook cell 6.
Switch to the state-space view, technology against liquidity. Find the low point of the digital path and the jump in the restructuring path. What would a before-and-after slide hide from the board?
Figure 1.3's view. Dots mark each option at the chosen month; the dashed step is the sale.
Turn on the uncertainty fan for the digital option's liquidity. How wide is the spread of outcomes around month 21? What does that suggest about how the program should be financed?
Worked Example 8.1: the plan, plus surprises that carry 60 percent into the next quarter (sd $50 million) and funding windows that close about once a decade, each closure removing on average $120 million. 100,000 paths, random seed 8. The band holds 80 percent of the paths (P10 to P90), the inner band 50 percent. Floor: $350 million (Table 5.4).
In the scorecard panel, choose weights for the readings and ask AXIOM to find two clearly different Meridians with the same score. Try at least three different weightings. Does any weighting avoid ties?
Weights move in steps of 0.05 and sum to 1; strategic risk takes what the other three leave, and counts against the score.
With the CFO's weights digital leads, 47.1 against 46.1. About $25 million more from the sale (4.05 liquidity points) lifts the restructuring to the same 47.1, yet the two Year-5 companies are very different: one has the modern platform, the other the cash and the lower risk (Worked Example 1.1, Steps 3 and 4). Moving 1.6 points of weight from technology to liquidity ties the two as they stand (Table 1.4).
No weighting avoids ties. A weighted score gives the same value to every pair of states whose difference is perpendicular to the weights, a set of dimension 7 in the eight readings, and any score that moves smoothly with the readings ties some clearly different companies too (Proposition 1.2; Online Appendix 1.B).
Worked Example 1.1, Steps 3, 4 and 6; Table 1.4; Proposition 1.2; notebook cell 13.
The digital path's liquidity trough around month 21; the restructuring's jump at the sale date; and the fact that every scorecard you build produces ties between genuinely different companies (Proposition 1.2 at work).
State which option deserves full analysis, the numbers that support your view, and what the scorecard cannot tell the board.