Energy
MISO Prices Power with Its Multipliers
MISO, the Midcontinent (formerly Midwest) Independent System Operator, which at the time of its award ran the grid and the wholesale power markets of 13 Midwestern U.S. states
$2.1–3.0 billion saved in 2007–2010, by MISO's estimate
Franz Edelman Award, 2011
Every five minutes, MISO decides how much each power plant on its grid should produce, and the price of energy at every point of it; around the time of its award, that meant more than 1,500 plants and about 40 million people. Those prices are the shadow prices of an optimization. By MISO's estimate, its markets let the region save $2.1 to $3.0 billion from 2007 through 2010, and the work won the 2011 Franz Edelman Award. What happens when a model's multipliers become the market's prices?
At a Glance
- Decision
- Which power plants run, how much each produces every five minutes, and the price of energy at each point of the grid
- Method
- A mixed-integer program commits the plants; with commitments fixed, a dispatch problem sets output, and its shadow prices are the market's prices, widened since 2015 to include commitment costs (Theorems 3.4 and 3.5)
- Result
- Cumulative savings for the region of $2.1–3.0 billion from 2007 through 2010, by MISO's estimate; Franz Edelman Award, 2011
Questions for the board
- Which of our internal prices come from an optimization, and could someone outside the team check them (Theorem 3.4)?
- What does one more unit of each binding limit—a line, a budget, a floor—save, and who is told (Theorem 3.5)?
- Where our decisions are lumpy, how far from the best is the plan we accept, and is that gap reported (Proposition 3.2)?
- In the benefits we claim, which part did the model produce, and which came from other changes?
Company and organization names identify the organizations whose published decisions the cases discuss. They are trademarks of their respective owners; no affiliation with or endorsement by them is implied.






