Airlines
American Airlines Prices Its Last Seat
American Airlines and its operations research group, American Airlines Decision Technologies
$1.4 billion over three years, by American's estimate
Franz Edelman Award, 1991
In 1977 American Airlines launched its Super Saver fares. Robert Crandall, who named the practice yield management, saw that most flights left with empty seats that cost almost nothing to fill. The catch was every flight's dilemma: a seat sold cheaply in advance may turn away a full-fare passenger later. American put the benefit at $1.4 billion over three years and won the 1991 Franz Edelman Award. The founder of one rival put it bluntly: “That was the end of our run.” What is the last seat worth?
At a Glance
- Decision
- On every flight, which booking requests to accept at which fare, and how far to sell beyond the cabin
- Method
- Overbooking, discount allocation, and traffic management solved as three subproblems and combined into booking limits; the value of a seat by position; threshold rules (Proposition 7.1, Theorem 7.2)
- Result
- A quantifiable benefit of $1.4 billion over three years and an expected revenue contribution of over $500 million a year; Franz Edelman Award, 1991
Questions for the board
- What is a unit of our capacity worth at each position, and does every decision to sell or hold it use that value (Proposition 7.1)?
- Do our limits respond to demand as it arrives, and what is that response worth against a plan fixed in advance (Proposition 7.2(ii))?
- Where a large problem has been split into parts, who checks that their answers fit together?
- Do customers understand the rules our prices impose, and what would complexity cost us in their trust?
Company and organization names identify the organizations whose published decisions the cases discuss. They are trademarks of their respective owners; no affiliation with or endorsement by them is implied.






