Capital markets
Brokers Pace a Large Sale
Institutional brokers and their execution algorithms; Citigroup, which estimated the impact model from its own orders
An impact model estimated from 29,509 orders
Sell a large block of shares fast and your own selling pushes the price down; sell slowly and the market may move against you before you finish. Robert Almgren and Neil Chriss turned that dilemma into an optimal trading schedule. A Citigroup team, estimating the impact model from 29,509 of its own orders, reported in 2005 that it was being built into its execution software, and many brokers now offer algorithms that minimize implementation shortfall. How fast should you exit a position you cannot sell at once?
At a Glance
- Decision
- How fast to sell (or buy) a large block of shares before a deadline
- Method
- Almgren and Chriss's mean–variance model: the impact cost of trading fast against the price risk of trading slowly; a linear–quadratic problem whose best schedule is also a linear rule (Theorems 8.1 and 8.3)
- Result
- Algorithms that minimize implementation shortfall, offered by many brokers; Citigroup reported in 2005 that its impact model, estimated from 29,509 orders, was being implemented in its execution software
Questions for the board
- When we must exit a position—a business, a market, a hedge—what does speed cost us, and what does waiting risk (Theorem 8.3)?
- Have we measured those costs, or only assumed their shape?
- Does our schedule respond to what we learn while we carry it out?
- Who decides how much risk we will bear to save cost, and is that decision written down?
Company and organization names identify the organizations whose published decisions the cases discuss. They are trademarks of their respective owners; no affiliation with or endorsement by them is implied.






