Automotive
Ford Maps Its Supply Risk Without Odds
Ford Motor Company's procurement organization, with researchers led by David Simchi-Levi of MIT
408 very-high-impact sites among 4,534 examined
INFORMS Daniel H. Wagner Prize, 2014
Ford bought from 1,400 Tier 1 suppliers at 4,400 sites, and its managers reckoned that a traditional risk analysis of them would take two or three years and be obsolete on arrival. So Ford, with a team led by MIT's David Simchi-Levi, asked a question with no probabilities at all: if this site went down, how long would recovery take, and what would it cost? Some of the largest exposures sat in unlikely places, such as a low-cost sensor that procurement was paying little attention to. Where is your risk hiding?
At a Glance
- Decision
- Where to spend limited risk-management effort across thousands of supplier sites, and how to respond when a site goes down
- Method
- Every node of the supply network disrupted in turn for its time to recover, with no probabilities; the best response to each disruption found by a linear program; exposures ranked against the worst; a time to survive as a guarantee (Definition 10.1, Proposition 10.1)
- Result
- Some of the largest exposures found in low-cost parts; about 1,500 more supplier sites slated for a larger share of risk resources, and over 400 monitored sites found to pose insignificant exposure; 2014 INFORMS Wagner Prize
Questions for the board
- Which suppliers, systems, or sites would stop us longest if they failed, whatever the cause (Definition 10.1)?
- Is our risk effort allocated by exposure or by spend?
- For each critical node, how long can we run without it, and how sure are we of the time it would take to recover?
- What set of events does our guarantee cover, and who audited it (Proposition 10.1)?
Company and organization names identify the organizations whose published decisions the cases discuss. They are trademarks of their respective owners; no affiliation with or endorsement by them is implied.






