Water
Seven States Plan for Four Colorado Rivers
The U.S. Bureau of Reclamation and the seven Colorado River Basin States, with analysts from RAND
Futures with Lake Mead below 1,000 feet cut from about 19 to 3 percent
Nearly 40 million Americans rely on the Colorado River for drinking water. Planning to 2060, the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation and the seven Basin States faced four descriptions of the river's future: a century of records, reconstructions spanning nearly 1,250 years, a blend of the two, and 112 climate projections. They relied on none of them alone. Against the observed record, the climate projections raised the 2060 annual bill by $1.1 billion at the low end and $2.3 billion at the high end. How do you plan when you cannot know the odds?
At a Glance
- Decision
- How to close the gap between the river's supply and the demands on it through 2060, without knowing which description of its future flows is right
- Method
- Four statistical descriptions of supply—from a century of observed flows, from reconstructions of nearly 1,250 years, a blend of the two, and 112 downscaled climate projections—crossed with six scenarios of demand; every portfolio of options simulated under all of them (Definition 11.1, Theorem 11.1, Proposition 11.2)
- Result
- A projected imbalance of about 3.2 million acre-feet by 2060; annual portfolio costs in 2060 of $2.5–3.5 billion at the median of the observed flows and $3.6–5.8 billion at the median of the climate projections; futures with Lake Mead below 1,000 feet cut from about 19 to 3 percent
Questions for the board
- Which law are we planning on, and what other laws would our records allow (Proposition 11.2)?
- Have we judged our plan under every law in that family, or only under the one we declared (Theorem 11.1)?
- What does our doubt cost: how far does the bill move from the kindest law to the harshest?
- Which conditions—not which probabilities—would break our plan, and how would we know that they had arrived?
Company and organization names identify the organizations whose published decisions the cases discuss. They are trademarks of their respective owners; no affiliation with or endorsement by them is implied.






