Rail
Dutch Railways Weigh More Trains Against Punctuality
Netherlands Railways (NS), with ProRail, the infrastructure manager, and researchers at CWI and Erasmus University Rotterdam
A record 87 percent punctuality in 2007
Franz Edelman Award, 2008
In December 2006 Netherlands Railways replaced a national timetable last overhauled in 1970, on a heavily used network where the alternative, doubling about 40 kilometers of track, would have cost about a billion euros. More trains or better punctuality? NS's board picked two of about ten radically different timetables, scored on punctuality, attractiveness to passengers and cost, and asked for one combining the best of both. Punctuality reached a record 87 percent in 2007, and the work won the 2008 Franz Edelman Award. Who should choose on a frontier?
At a Glance
- Decision
- A completely new national timetable, introduced in December 2006, with the rolling stock and crew schedules to run it
- Method
- About ten radically different candidate timetables, each scored on punctuality, attractiveness to passengers, and operating cost, and a choice by the board; rolling stock planned by weighted sums of conflicting criteria (Theorems 12.1 and 12.2, Proposition 12.1)
- Result
- Annual profit up 40 million euros, expected to reach 70 million; punctuality a record 87 percent in 2007, from 84.8; 2008 Franz Edelman Award
Questions for the board
- Which of our objectives conflict, and have we seen candidates that trade them, each scored on all of them (Theorem 12.1)?
- Whose preference selects among them, and is it written down (Proposition 12.1)?
- What do our weights stand for, and what would a different weighting choose (Theorem 12.2)?
- When the losers of a trade-off object, who decides whether to move along the frontier, and at what price?
Company and organization names identify the organizations whose published decisions the cases discuss. They are trademarks of their respective owners; no affiliation with or endorsement by them is implied.






