CS-018failure
J. C. Penney Company, Inc.
'Fair and Square' pricing and store reinvention under CEO Ron Johnson (2011-2013)
- Region
- North America
- Country
- United States
- Industry
- General Merchandise and Department Stores (Specialty Retail and Omnichannel Commerce)
- Functions
- Marketing & Go-to-Market, Sales & Revenue Operations, Strategy, Corporate Development & Transformation Office, Customer Experience & Support, HR & Workforce
- Topics
- Revenue growth has stalled; Pricing and customer profitability are deteriorating; Customer churn and dissatisfaction are accelerating; The business model is being disrupted; Cash is trapped and liquidity is tightening
- Starting situation
- New initiative
- Period
- 2011–2013
- Last verified
- 1 November 2026
Executive summary
In November 2011 J.C. Penney, a US department-store chain with 1,102 stores and $17.26bn of sales, appointed Ron Johnson, the executive who had led Apple's retail stores, as chief executive at the urging of activist shareholders [C01, C03, C05, C07]. In January 2012 he replaced the company's hundreds of yearly promotions with 'Fair and Square' everyday pricing and announced a plan to rebuild every store as a street of branded shops [C08, C10]. Within a year sales had fallen by a quarter, the promotional strategy had been partly reversed, and in April 2013 the board reinstated his predecessor [C16, C19, C23].
The three numbers that matter, all from the company's 10-Ks: comparable store sales down 25.2% in fiscal 2012 [C16]; a net loss from continuing operations of $985m against $152m a year earlier [C06, C17]; and a gross margin rate down from 36.0% to 31.3% even though promotions were supposed to end [C17]. The company itself had warned in March 2012 that the pricing change could cause a prolonged decline in sales [C09].
KB analysis — the one lesson: a change to how customers are asked to pay is a change to their behaviour, and it can be tested on a few stores before it is imposed on a thousand; here, by the company's own later admission, the pricing change was the error [C22, C24].
Outcome: failure
The initiative was abandoned, exited or written down, or an official finding called it a failure.
Basis of the outcome
In the first year of the transformation net sales fell 24.8%, comparable store sales 25.2%, and the net loss from continuing operations rose to $985m (fiscal 2012 10-K, S02). The company discontinued and then partly reintroduced its promotional strategy, the CEO publicly called the pricing policy a mistake (S09), and the board replaced him with his predecessor after 17 months (S03). The strategy was reversed; the KB rests the classification on these documented facts.
Key figures
| Phase | Figure | Value | When | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before | Net sales | $17.76bn → $17.26bn | FY2010 → FY2011 | audited_filing |
| Before | Comparable store sales | +2.5% → +0.2% | FY2010 → FY2011 | audited_filing |
| Before | Promotions / revenue at ≥50% off | 590 / almost 73% | 2011 | company_reported |
| Before | Activist stake | 36% (Pershing Square and Vornado) | late 2010 | press_reported |
| Before | Stores / associates | 1,102 / about 159,000 | Jan 2012 | audited_filing |
| During | CEO's own investment | $50m in warrants | Jun 2011 | press_reported |
| During | Q1 same-store sales | −19% | Q1 2012 | press_reported |
| During | Dividend | discontinued | 15 May 2012 | regulatory_filing_unaudited |
| After | Net sales | $12,985m (−24.8%) | FY2012 | audited_filing |
| After | Comparable store sales | −25.2% | FY2012 | audited_filing |
| After | Gross margin rate | 36.0% → 31.3% | FY2011 → FY2012 | audited_filing |
| After | Net loss, continuing operations | $152m → $985m | FY2011 → FY2012 | audited_filing |
| After | Employees | about 159,000 → about 116,000 | Jan 2012 → Feb 2013 | regulatory_filing_unaudited |
| After | Term loan arranged | $1.75bn (Goldman Sachs) | May 2013 | regulatory_filing_unaudited |
- audited_filing
- A figure in audited financial statements, such as an annual report's financial statements or a 10-K.
- company_reported
- A company statement, press release or investor presentation that no one has independently checked.
- press_reported
- A journalist's own reporting.
- regulatory_filing_unaudited
- Text in an 8-K, 6-K or 10-Q, which is filed with a regulator but not audited.
Practices this case bears on
- SupportsLimit how many things change at once, for the business and for the customer BP-012
- Counter-exampleRenew the leadership team quickly, choosing leaders from where the business is going BP-029
- SupportsSecure the owners' backing and patience in advance, engage challengers on the evidence, and hold course through early setbacks BP-032
- SupportsWrite exit and pause criteria at approval, and treat impairments as triggers to re-test the strategy BP-042
- SupportsSecure the cash runway before you need it, and measure liquidity at its worst point BP-044
- SupportsValidate the proposition with the target customers' own evidence and a control-market pilot before a national launch BP-057
Sources
- S01 J. C. Penney Company, Inc. Form 10-K for fiscal 2011 (year ended 28 January 2012) · J. C. Penney Company, Inc., J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2012-03 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S02 J. C. Penney Company, Inc. Form 10-K for fiscal 2012 (year ended 2 February 2013) · J. C. Penney Company, Inc., J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-03 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S03 JCPenney Appoints Myron E. (Mike) Ullman, III Chief Executive Officer, Succeeding Ron Johnson (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1) · not stated, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-04-08 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S04 JCPenney reports first quarter 2013 results (Form 8-K exhibit) · not stated, J. C. Penney Company, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-05-15 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S05 JC Penney nabs Apple exec as new CEO · not stated, CNNMoney, 2011-06-14 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S06 JCPenney: lower everyday prices, fewer sales · Shan Li, Christian Science Monitor (Los Angeles Times/MCT), 2012-01-26 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S07 Is JC Penney's Makeover the Future of Retailing? · Kim Girard, Harvard Business School Working Knowledge, 2012-03-05 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S08 J.C. Penney stock plunges on president's exit · not stated, CNNMoney, 2012-06-19 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S09 J.C. Penney Lost Nearly $1 Billion in 2012 · Rob Bates, JCK, 2013-02-28 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S10 J.C. Penney's New Old CEO · Knowledge at Wharton staff, Knowledge at Wharton, 2013-04-10 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S11 J.C. Penney's revolution comes to a bloody end · Jennifer Reingold, Fortune, 2013-04-08 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S12 How Ron Johnson tried, and failed, to inject a bit of Apple culture into JC Penney · Yoni Heisler, Engadget, 2013-04-14 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S13 Bill Ackman sells JCPenney stake · not stated, CNNMoney, 2013-08-26 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S14 Earnings analysis: Is J.C. Penney back from the near dead? · Jennifer Reingold, Fortune, 2014-02-26 · accessed 2026-10-31
Researched and fact-checked knowledgebase · Knowledgebase built 5 November 2026 · Last verified 1 November 2026
Practices, their evidence grades and case summaries are public. Full case studies are available in AXIOM to subscribers and AXIOM Discover participants.

