Skip to content

All best practices

CS-021failure

Hewlett-Packard (HP; later Hewlett Packard Enterprise)

Acquisition of Autonomy Corporation plc (2011) and the US$8.8bn write-down (2012)

Region
North America, Western Europe
Country
United States, United Kingdom
Industry
Software and Internet (non-B2B) (B2B SaaS and Subscription Software)
Functions
Strategy, Corporate Development & Transformation Office, Risk, Compliance & Internal Audit, Finance & FP&A, IT, ERP & Digital
Topics
M&A integration or corporate complexity is destroying value; Investment capital is not generating returns; Revenue growth has stalled; The business model is being disrupted
Starting situation
New initiative
Period
2011–2026
Last verified
1 November 2026

Executive summary

In August 2011 Hewlett-Packard agreed to buy the British software company Autonomy for GBP 25.50 a share, announcing the deal on the same day as a review of its PC business and the end of its webOS devices [C01, C02]. Within five weeks the CEO who led the deal had been removed [C07], and 13 months after closing HP wrote down about US$8.8bn, attributing more than US$5bn to alleged accounting improprieties at Autonomy [C09, C12].

The three numbers that matter: the US$8.8bn impairment [C09]; the GBP 646m the English High Court assessed as HP's loss on the purchase price in 2025, about 10% below the price paid [C40, C41]; and more than 14 years from announcement to the High Court's March 2026 ruling on interest and permission to appeal, after which the estate applied to the Court of Appeal [C01, C45, C50]. Applying the civil standard of the balance of probabilities, the court found Autonomy's former CEO Mike Lynch and CFO Sushovan Hussain liable in fraud, chiefly over concealed hardware reselling and reseller transactions without commercial substance; both denied wrongdoing [C28, C31, C32, C51, C35]. It also found HP's own claim 'always substantially exaggerated' [C41]. Lynch was acquitted in a US criminal trial in 2024 and died later that year; Hussain was convicted in the US in 2018 [C37, C39, C22].

The one lesson: in an acquisition that is meant to transform the buyer, the diligence and governance must test the quality of the target's revenue independently of its audited accounts, and the board must own that test rather than the strategy function that wants the deal [C14, C15, C25, C29].

Outcome: failure

The initiative was abandoned, exited or written down, or an official finding called it a failure.

Basis of the outcome

HP wrote down US$8.8bn of the acquisition 13 months after closing and attributed more than US$5bn of it to alleged accounting improprieties. The English High Court later found, on the civil standard of the balance of probabilities, that Autonomy's former CEO and CFO were liable to HP in fraud (both denied wrongdoing), and assessed HP's loss on the purchase price at about GBP 646m — a fraction of the write-down and of the roughly US$4–5bn HP had claimed.

Key figures

PhaseFigureValueWhenVerification
BeforeOffer priceGBP 25.50 per share (about US$42.11)18 Aug 2011regulatory_filing_unaudited
BeforeHP quarterly revenue / GAAP net earningsUS$31.2bn / US$1.9bnQ3 FY2011regulatory_filing_unaudited
BeforeHP market value during Apotheker's tenurefell by nearly halfNov 2010–Sep 2011press_reported
DuringShares acquired at completionjust over 87% (213.4m shares)3 Oct 2011press_reported
DuringAutonomy impairment chargeabout US$8.8bn (non-cash)20 Nov 2012regulatory_filing_unaudited
DuringPortion attributed by HP to alleged improprietiesmore than US$5bn (Lesjak: about US$5bn; US$3.8bn share price)Nov 2012company_reported
DuringHP FY2012 GAAP net loss / total impairmentsUS$12.7bn / US$18.0bnFY2012regulatory_filing_unaudited
DuringRevenue inflation alleged by US prosecutors (as much as)14.6% (2009), 17.9% (2010), 21.5% (Q1 2011), 12.4% (Q2 2011)2019 releaseofficial_statement
DuringConcealed hardware sales (US prosecutors)US$53.3m (2009), US$99.08m (2010)2019 releaseofficial_statement
AfterDeloitte fine (disciplinary tribunal)GBP 15mSep 2020official_finding
AfterPleaded loss under FSMAat least US$4.55bn2022official_finding
AfterDamages assessed (UK High Court)more than GBP 700m (about US$943m), incl. GBP 646m on price22 Jul 2025official_finding
AfterCourt's value per share vs price paidGBP 23.00 vs GBP 25.50 (−9.8%)Jul 2025official_finding
AfterInterest ordered / claimants' costsabout US$236m / at least GBP 120m2026press_reported
AfterSettlements creditedDeloitte US$45m; Hussain about US$104m2026official_finding
regulatory_filing_unaudited
Text in an 8-K, 6-K or 10-Q, which is filed with a regulator but not audited.
press_reported
A journalist's own reporting.
company_reported
A company statement, press release or investor presentation that no one has independently checked.
official_statement
A government or ministerial statement. It is official, but political, and is not a finding.
official_finding
A finding of an inquiry, court or regulator.

Sources

  1. S01 HP Reports Third Quarter 2011 Results and Initiates Company Transformation (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1) · Hewlett-Packard Company, Hewlett-Packard Company / US SEC, 2011-08-18 · accessed 2026-10-31
  2. S02 HP Ousts CEO Apotheker · Jeffrey Schwartz, Enterprise Systems Journal (Redmond), 2011-09-22 · accessed 2026-10-31
  3. S03 HP's Autonomy Buyout Finalized And Official · Devin Coldewey, TechCrunch, 2011-10-03 · accessed 2026-10-31
  4. S04 HP Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2012 Results (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1) · Hewlett-Packard Company, Hewlett-Packard Company / US SEC, 2012-11-20 · accessed 2026-10-31
  5. S05 HP alleges Autonomy fraud (write-down report) · Timothy Prickett Morgan, The Register, 2012-11-20 · accessed 2026-10-31
  6. S06 HP takes USD 8.8 bn hit, alleges accounting fraud in Autonomy · Press Trust of India, Business Standard (PTI), 2012-11-20 · accessed 2026-10-31
  7. S07 Mike Lynch rejects HP's claims – accuses tech giant of mismanaging Autonomy · Silicon Republic, 2012-11-21 · accessed 2026-10-31
  8. S08 Lynch declares innocence in open letter to HP board; HP fires back · Chris Kanaracus, PCWorld (IDG News Service), 2012-11-27 · accessed 2026-10-31
  9. S09 HP Autonomy investigation (news release) · Serious Fraud Office, UK Serious Fraud Office, 2015-01-19 · accessed 2026-10-31
  10. S10 Former Autonomy CFO Sentenced To 60 Months In Prison · US Department of Justice, US Attorney's Office, Northern District of California, 2019-05-13 · accessed 2026-10-31
  11. S11 Autonomy: Deloitte auditors fined £15m · The Register, 2020-09-17 · accessed 2026-10-31
  12. S12 Mike Lynch Loses $5 Billion Court Fight With HP Over Autonomy · Bloomberg News, Bloomberg News (republished by Data Center Knowledge), 2022-01-28 · accessed 2026-10-31
  13. S13 Key Issues From a Summary of the Findings in the Claim Brought by HP Following the Troubled Purchase of Autonomy · Oliver Glynn-Jones, Alasdair McAlpine, Goodwin Procter LLP, 2022-02-09 · accessed 2026-10-31
  14. S14 Hewlett-Packard succeeds in landmark Autonomy case: full judgment handed down · One Essex Court, One Essex Court (barristers' chambers), 2022-05-18 · accessed 2026-10-31
  15. S15 Lynch to appeal as judge details Autonomy case conclusions · Dan Robinson, The Register, 2022-05-18 · accessed 2026-10-31
  16. S16 Mike Lynch cleared of fraud charges in US trial · Thomas Claburn, Chris Williams, The Register, 2024-06-06 · accessed 2026-10-31
  17. S17 UK court says HPE owed more than $940 million in fraud case against late tech tycoon Mike Lynch · Kelvin Chan, Associated Press (via Yahoo Finance), 2025-07-22 · accessed 2026-10-31
  18. S18 Judge questions HP's exaggerated Autonomy loss claim · Computer Weekly, 2025-07-22 · accessed 2026-10-31
  19. S19 Lynch estate ordered to pay £700m following Autonomy trial · Law Society Gazette, 2025-07-22 · accessed 2026-10-31
  20. S20 ACL Netherlands v Sandelson: currency risk, interest and the Autonomy fraud aftermath · Solicitors Journal, 2026-03-24 · accessed 2026-10-31
  21. S21 Biggest civil fraud trial concludes with £177m award · Law Society Gazette, 2026 · accessed 2026-10-31
  22. S22 ACL Netherlands BV & Ors v Sandelson & Ors [2026] EWHC 691 (Ch), approved consequentials judgment · Mr Justice Hildyard, High Court of England and Wales (Chancery Division), via Courts and Tribunals Judiciary, 2026-03-24 · accessed 2026-11-01
  23. S23 Autonomy Corporation and others v Lynch and another: press summary of the quantum judgment [2025] EWHC 1877 (Ch) · Mr Justice Hildyard, High Court of England and Wales (Chancery Division), via Courts and Tribunals Judiciary, 2025-07-22 · accessed 2026-11-01
  24. S24 Key findings in the Autonomy consequentials judgment · Stewarts Law LLP, 2026-06-09 · accessed 2026-11-01
  25. S25 ACL Netherlands BV & Ors v Lynch & Anor [2022] EWHC 1178 (Ch), liability judgment · Mr Justice Hildyard, The National Archives, Find Case Law, 2022-05-17 · accessed 2026-11-01

Researched and fact-checked knowledgebase · Knowledgebase built 5 November 2026 · Last verified 1 November 2026

Practices, their evidence grades and case summaries are public. Full case studies are available in AXIOM to subscribers and AXIOM Discover participants.