Skip to content

All best practices

CS-166mixed

Zappos.com (Zappos), Las Vegas-based online shoe and apparel retailer, a subsidiary of Amazon since 2009

Company-wide move to Holacracy and self-management, the 'Road to Teal' ultimatum and the later shift to market-based internal teams (2013-2020)

Region
North America
Country
United States
Industry
Specialty Retail and Omnichannel Commerce
Functions
HR & Workforce, Strategy, Corporate Development & Transformation Office, Customer Experience & Support, IT, ERP & Digital, Operations & Service Delivery
Topics
Bureaucracy and slow decisions prevent agility; Transformation fatigue is causing initiatives to fail; Competing transformation programs overwhelm resources; Critical skills are missing or becoming obsolete
Starting situation
New initiative
Period
2013–2020
Last verified
5 November 2026

Executive summary

Zappos, the Amazon-owned online shoe retailer with about 1,500 staff, began replacing its management hierarchy with Holacracy in 2013, a system of self-organising circles and roles [C01, C02]. After more than a year of running both systems side by side, the chief executive told staff in March 2015 to commit to self-management or leave with severance [C05, C06].

About 18% of the company took the offer and turnover reached 29% in a year; Zappos dropped off Fortune's best-employers list and a major systems migration slipped [C11, C13, C16]. Profit, by Fortune's account, hit a record in 2015 [C17]. By 2020 managers had returned, the formal meeting system had been dropped, and teams ran as internal businesses with their own profit-and-loss statements [C23].

The numbers that matter: 260 departures through the buyout (about 18%), 29% total turnover in a year, scores down on 48 of 58 workplace survey questions, and a system that by 2020 had about 460 circles and 4,700 roles [C11, C16, C23]. The lesson: a culture change imposed as an ultimatum, at the same time as other major programmes, buys speed at the cost of the people and the knowledge the other programmes depend on.

Outcome: mixed

Documented shortfalls or reversals sit alongside documented gains. For example: an initial failure later recovered, or a strategic goal met while a major adverse event in the same programme was recorded.

Basis of the outcome

Gains: Fortune reported that Zappos posted its highest operating profit ever and met its 2015 profit goals in the year the ultimatum took effect (S14); self-management stayed in place, with hundreds of circles and thousands of roles still reported in 2020 (S15, S16). Shortfalls: 260 employees, about 18% of the company, took the buyout (S09, S10, S12), and total turnover reached 29% in a year (S14); Zappos fell off Fortune's Best Companies to Work For list for the first time in eight years, with scores down on 48 of 58 survey questions (S14); the Amazon platform migration missed its 2015 deadline after 38% of its team took the offer (S12, S13); and by 2020 managers had returned and the rigid Holacracy meeting structure had been dropped (S16, S17). Documented gains alongside documented shortfalls and a partial reversal meet the mixed criterion.

Key figures

PhaseFigureValueWhenVerification
BeforeEmployeesabout 1,500Jan 2014press_reported
BeforePilot group100 staff, mostly HRMar 2013press_reported
BeforeCircles plannedabout 400Jan 2014press_reported
DuringStaff in circlesabout 80%Late 2014press_reported
DuringMemo lengthabout 4,300-5,000 wordsMar 2015press_reported
DuringFirst-round takers210 of 1,503 (about 14%)Apr 2015press_reported
DuringSeverance offeredat least three months' payApr 2015press_reported
AfterTotal buyout departures260 (about 18%)Jan 2016press_reported
AfterSuper Cloud team who left38%Jan 2016press_reported
AfterTurnover in a year29%Mar 2016press_reported
AfterSurvey questions with lower scores48 of 58Mar 2016press_reported
AfterCircles and rolesabout 460 and 4,7002020press_reported
AfterCircle growth target5% each by end-2020 (about US$100m)2020press_reported
press_reported
A journalist's own reporting.

Sources

  1. S01 Zappos to embrace 'holacracy,' rejecting all job titles · Roger Riddell, Retail Dive, 2014-01-06 · accessed 2026-11-04
  2. S02 Holacracy at Zappos: It's either the future of management or a social experiment gone awry · not stated, Quartz, 2014-12 · accessed 2026-11-04
  3. S03 Here's what happened to Zappos' HR boss when the company got rid of managers and her job became obsolete · not stated (Richard Feloni credited for images), Business Insider India (republishing Business Insider), 2016 · accessed 2026-11-04
  4. S04 Tony Hsieh's big Zappos management experiment looks increasingly troubled · not stated, Quartz, 2015-05 · accessed 2026-11-04
  5. S05 Looks Like Zappos' Self-Management System Isn't for Everyone · Richard Feloni, Entrepreneur (republishing Business Insider), 2015-05-11 · accessed 2026-11-04
  6. S06 A few months into Holacracy, Zappos is seeing small successes · Tom Starner, HR Dive, 2015-07-20 · accessed 2026-11-04
  7. S07 What is Holacracy and why does it work for Zappos? · Sarah K. White, CIO, 2015-08-05 · accessed 2026-11-04
  8. S08 When Zappos got rid of managers, some underperforming employees entered a limbo known as 'The Beach' · not stated, Business Insider India (republishing Business Insider), 2015 · accessed 2026-11-04
  9. S09 Zappos has now lost 18% of its employees to its radical buyout offer · not stated, Quartz, 2016-01 · accessed 2026-11-04
  10. S10 Another 50 Zappos employees take buyouts · not stated, Las Vegas Sun, 2016-01-13 · accessed 2026-11-04
  11. S11 Zappos' Weird Management Style Is Costing It More Employees · Lauren French, Fortune (republishing TIME), 2016-01-14 · accessed 2026-11-04
  12. S12 Zappos' workforce exodus continues, hits 18% · Tom Starner, HR Dive, 2016-01-14 · accessed 2026-11-04
  13. S13 Zappos CEO Tony Hsieh explains why 18% of employees quit during the company's radical management experiment · Richard Feloni, Business Insider India (republishing Business Insider), 2016-01 · accessed 2026-11-04
  14. S14 How a Radical Shift Left Zappos Reeling · Jennifer Reingold, Fortune, 2016-03-04 · accessed 2026-11-04
  15. S15 'Safe enough to try': An interview with Zappos CEO Tony Hsieh · Aaron De Smet and Chris Gagnon (interviewers), McKinsey Quarterly, 2017-10-19 · accessed 2026-11-04
  16. S16 Zappos has quietly backed away from holacracy · Aimee Groth, Quartz, 2020-01 · accessed 2026-11-04
  17. S17 Zappos CEO Tony Hsieh's Biggest Management Experiment Is Evolving Again (in a Very Intriguing Way) · Cameron Albert-Deitch, Inc., 2020-01-30 · accessed 2026-11-04
  18. S18 Zappos CEO retiring after 20 years leading shoe seller · Associated Press, The Washington Times (Associated Press), 2020-08-25 · accessed 2026-11-04

Researched and fact-checked knowledgebase · Knowledgebase built 5 November 2026 · Last verified 5 November 2026

Practices, their evidence grades and case summaries are public. Full case studies are available in AXIOM to subscribers and AXIOM Discover participants.