Skip to content

All best practices

CS-099failure

Avon Products, Inc.

Service Model Transformation (SMT), the SAP-based order-management programme piloted in Canada as 'Promise' (2009–2013)

Region
North America
Country
United States, Canada
Industry
Consumer Goods (non-food: toys, apparel, personal care) (Discrete Manufacturing)
Functions
IT, ERP & Digital, Sales & Revenue Operations, Customer Experience & Support, Supply Chain & Logistics
Topics
Legacy ERP and fragmented systems block execution; Cross-functional processes are slow and broken; Technology spending is growing without business returns; Customer churn and dissatisfaction are accelerating
Starting situation
In-flight initiative
Period
2009–2013
Last verified
1 November 2026

Executive summary

In 2009 Avon Products began the Service Model Transformation (SMT), a global SAP-based programme to replace its order-management system and change how its millions of independent Representatives dealt with the company [C02, C06]. Its first live deployment, branded 'Promise' in Canada, launched in May 2013 [C07]. Avon said the pilot caused significant business disruption and showed no clear return, and in December 2013 halted the roll-out everywhere else [C05].

The three numbers that matter: a US$117.2m impairment of SMT's capitalised software [C02]; a 16% fall in North American active Representatives in the third quarter of 2013 [C03]; and about four years from the programme's start to its first deployment [C02, C07, C10].

Outcome: classed failure. The programme was halted beyond its pilot market and its capitalised software was written down [C02, C05].

The one lesson, as the KB reads it: when the users of a system are independent sellers who can leave, the system's success is measured by whether they stay, and a pilot has to be stopped on that measure before it spreads [C03, C06, C07].

Outcome: failure

The initiative was abandoned, exited or written down, or an official finding called it a failure.

Basis of the outcome

The programme was halted beyond its pilot market in December 2013, and its capitalised software was written down by US$117.2m (Avon 8-K, S01; Form 10-K, S02). Avon said the Canadian pilot caused significant business disruption and showed no clear return on investment (S01, S02). The system remained in use in Canada only. This meets §4.3's failure criterion (abandoned and written down). The class rests on the halt and the impairment, which Avon itself reported; it does not depend on any of the four competing accounts of the cause.

Key figures

PhaseFigureValueWhenVerification
BeforeRevenueUS$10,561.4m2012regulatory_filing_unaudited
BeforeProgramme start20092009regulatory_filing_unaudited
BeforeActive Representatives; employees>6 million; about 36,7002013regulatory_filing_unaudited
DuringCanada go-live ('Promise')May 20132013press_reported
DuringActive Representatives, North America−16%Q3 2013regulatory_filing_unaudited
DuringNorth America revenue; operating resultUS$328.6m (−19%); −US$32.7m (from −US$8.8m)Q3 2013regulatory_filing_unaudited
DuringRepresentatives lost in Canada (one sales leader's estimate)up to 16,000Dec 2013press_reported_unconfirmed
AfterSoftware carrying value; expected chargeabout US$125m; US$100m–125m9 Dec 2013regulatory_filing_unaudited
AfterSMT impairment recordedUS$117.2m (non-cash)FY2013regulatory_filing_unaudited
AfterPositions eliminated (incl. SMT roles)about 650Dec 2013regulatory_filing_unaudited
AfterRevenueUS$9,955.0m2013regulatory_filing_unaudited
AfterNet result from continuing operationsloss of about US$1m2013press_reported
AfterActive Representatives (total)−5%Q4 2013press_reported
regulatory_filing_unaudited
Text in an 8-K, 6-K or 10-Q, which is filed with a regulator but not audited.
press_reported
A journalist's own reporting.
press_reported_unconfirmed
A press figure the company declined to confirm, or one attributed to unnamed observers.

Sources

  1. S01 Avon Products, Inc. Form 8-K (event of 9 December 2013) · Avon Products, Inc., Avon Products, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-12-11 · accessed 2026-11-01
  2. S02 Avon Products, Inc. Form 10-K for fiscal year 2013 · Avon Products, Inc., Avon Products, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2014-02 · accessed 2026-11-01
  3. S03 Avon third-quarter 2013 results (Exhibit 99.1 to Form 8-K) · Avon Products, Inc., Avon Products, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-10-31 · accessed 2026-11-01
  4. S04 Avon Products, Inc. Form 10-Q for the quarter ended 30 September 2013 · Avon Products, Inc., Avon Products, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2013-10 · accessed 2026-11-01
  5. S05 Avon Products, Inc. Form 8-K (appointment of Sherilyn McCoy) · Avon Products, Inc., Avon Products, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), 2012-04-04 · accessed 2026-11-01
  6. S06 Avon halts work on big SAP implementation, cites lack of ROI · Chris Kanaracus, Computerworld (IDG News Service), 2013-12-12 · accessed 2026-11-01
  7. S07 Inside Avon's Failed Order-Management Project · Doug Henschen, InformationWeek, 2013-12-16 · accessed 2026-11-01
  8. S08 Avon Pulls Plug On $125 Million SAP Project · Doug Henschen, InformationWeek, 2013-12-12 · accessed 2026-11-01
  9. S09 Avon drops SAP big bang transformation · not stated, Computer Weekly, 2013-12 · accessed 2026-11-01
  10. S10 Avon to SAP: a failure in program risk management · John Belden, UpperEdge, 2013-12-13 · accessed 2026-11-01
  11. S11 Avon revenue slides in North America as sales force shrinks · Reuters, FashionNetwork (Reuters), 2013-10-31 · accessed 2026-11-01
  12. S12 Avon's 2013 results not so pretty · not stated, Happi, 2014-02-13 · accessed 2026-11-01

Researched and fact-checked knowledgebase · Knowledgebase built 5 November 2026 · Last verified 1 November 2026

Practices, their evidence grades and case summaries are public. Full case studies are available in AXIOM to subscribers and AXIOM Discover participants.