Skip to content

All best practices

BP-007Grade B41 supporting cases (40 counted), 0 counter-examples

When the thesis has failed, exit in one decisive move and say what is kept

The practice

Once the evidence shows an initiative's thesis has failed, take the whole decision at once (exit, write-down or reversal), state why, and say clearly which assets and capabilities are kept.

Why it works

Sunk cost, reputation and the hope of a turn keep failing initiatives alive; in the KB cases where the exit was delayed (AOL Time Warner, Tata Steel) the losses kept growing while attention stayed on the failed bet. A single decisive move ends the drain and lets the organisation and investors re-plan from a known base. Stating why the thesis failed separates the decision from blame and preserves credibility for the next bet. Saying what is kept matters as much as the exit: in several cases the valuable parts (the NHS national services, Lidl's SAP relationship, IBM's health data assets) survived the stop and were named when it was announced; the KB reads naming them as part of why they kept their value. Exiting while the business still has a buyer preserves more value than exiting after it has none. The counter-risk is exiting on noise; the trigger should be the thesis, not one bad quarter (see BP-042).

KB synthesis: the mechanism is the knowledgebase's own reasoning, drawn from the member lessons. Factual support is the case claims under evidence.cases and the research under evidence.research (R-refs).

How to apply it

  • State the original thesis in a sentence and test the evidence against it, not against the budget.
  • When the thesis fails, announce the exit, the write-down and the people provisions together.
  • List what is kept (assets, capabilities, working components, customers) and who owns each.
  • Exit while there is still a buyer; map buyers and legacy liabilities before you need them.
  • Treat a change of direction as a formal decision with a write-off attached, recorded at the board.

Warning signs

  • Successive 'resets' of the same initiative without a change in its thesis.
  • Write-downs arrive in instalments over several years.
  • The business's buyers are disappearing while the board debates.
  • No one can say which parts of the programme work.

When it applies

  • Large uncertain bets: acquisitions, market entries, platform builds and new product lines.
  • Businesses that cannot earn their cost of capital after repeated trimming.

When it does not

  • The trigger is a short-term or cyclical shock rather than a broken thesis.
  • The platform is sound and the failure is in execution; fix forward instead (CS-019).

Evidence grade: Grade B

At least 6 counted supporting cases for every 100 cases in the knowledgebase (6 × cases ÷ 100, rounded to the nearest whole number), whose primary regions span at least 4 regions.

Why this grade

Grade B by schema 4.10 route: >=14 counted cases across >=4 primary regions (the case bar is 6 per 100 cases in the knowledgebase, 235 cases). A needs a systematic, peer-reviewed study that tests this practice. None of the research cited in the KB does. 1 supporting case(s) rest only on company-reported claims and are not counted toward the grade.

Where it applies

Transformation type
  • T05 ERP and core systems
  • T09 Portfolio restructuring
  • T10 Market entry and expansion
Topic (business problem)
  • Investment capital is not generating returns
  • Cross-functional processes are slow and broken
  • Data cannot be trusted for critical decisions
  • Technology spending is growing without business returns
  • Energy, resource or climate exposure undermines economics
  • Competing transformation programs overwhelm resources
Function
  • Finance & FP&A
  • HR & Workforce
  • Strategy, Corporate Development & Transformation Office
Starting situation
  • New initiative
  • In-flight initiative
  • Completed (review)
Industry
  • B2B SaaS and Subscription Software
  • Chemicals and Process Manufacturing
  • Commercial Banking
  • Commercial Real Estate and REITs
  • Discrete Manufacturing
  • Electric Power Utilities
  • Grocery and Food Retail
  • Hospitals and Health Systems
  • Hotels, Lodging and Hospitality
  • Logistics, Warehousing and 3PL
  • Other (cross-industry)
  • Professional Services: Accounting, Law and Advisory
  • Renewable Fuels, Fueling Infrastructure and Credits
  • Specialty Retail and Omnichannel Commerce
  • Telecommunications, Broadband and Fiber
Region
  • Africa
  • Central and Eastern Europe
  • East Asia
  • Global
  • Latin America
  • Middle East
  • North America
  • Oceania
  • South Asia
  • Southeast Asia
  • Western Europe

Supporting and counter cases

Researched and fact-checked knowledgebase · Knowledgebase built 5 November 2026

Practices, their evidence grades and case summaries are public. Full case studies are available in AXIOM to subscribers and AXIOM Discover participants.