CS-019mixed
Hershey Foods Corporation (now The Hershey Company)
Enterprise-wide integrated information system (SAP R/3, Siebel, Manugistics) go-live, 1999
- Region
- North America
- Country
- United States
- Industry
- Food and Beverage Manufacturing
- Functions
- IT, ERP & Digital, Supply Chain & Logistics, Customer Experience & Support, Sales & Revenue Operations, Operations & Service Delivery
- Topics
- Legacy ERP and fragmented systems block execution; Service delivery is too slow, unreliable or expensive; Inventory is simultaneously excessive and unavailable; Cross-functional processes are slow and broken; Revenue growth has stalled
- Starting situation
- In-flight initiative
- Period
- 1996–2000
- Last verified
- 1 November 2026
Executive summary
In 1999 Hershey Foods, which described itself as a leader in North American confectionery, completed a replacement of most of its transaction systems, approved in late 1996, with an integrated package built on SAP R/3, Siebel and Manugistics software [C38, C01, C08]. The order-to-cash phase went live on 5 July 1999, three months later than planned and at the start of the back-to-school and Halloween shipping season [C05, C06]. Orders could not be shipped completely or on time, retailers filled empty shelves with competitors' products, and Hershey warned in September that earnings would fall short [C10, C12, C17].
The three numbers that matter, all from Hershey's own filings: third-quarter 1999 net sales down 12% to $1,066.7m [C13]; inventories up $120.6m in nine months, mainly finished goods [C14]; and total system commitments of $115m to $120m against an original estimate of about $110m [C02, C15]. The system was not abandoned: by the third quarter of 2000 profit had recovered, and Hershey later upgraded the same SAP platform [C31, C34].
KB analysis — the one lesson: when a cut-over slips, the new date must be tested against the business calendar, not only against the project plan; moving from a quiet April to a July start placed the riskiest phase in front of the year's heaviest demand [C06, C07].
Outcome: mixed
Documented shortfalls or reversals sit alongside documented gains. For example: an initial failure later recovered, or a strategic goal met while a major adverse event in the same programme was recorded.
Basis of the outcome
Schema §4.3 classes an initiative as a failure only if it was abandoned, exited or written down, or an official finding called it a failure. None of these applies: the filings read record no write-down or impairment of the system (S03, S04, S14), no official finding was found, and Hershey kept, fixed and later upgraded the same SAP platform (S08, S10, S11). The case therefore meets the 'mixed' criterion (an initial failure later recovered). On the negative side, Hershey's own filings record that the July 1999 start-up caused lost sales, lost market share, significantly higher freight and warehousing costs and higher inventories, and third-quarter net sales fell 12% (S02, S03). On the positive side, third-quarter profit recovered in 2000 (S08). The 1999 go-live itself remains a documented failure of execution.
Key figures
| Phase | Figure | Value | When | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before | Project approved / 1998 status | late 1996 / about 65% complete | 1996 / Dec 1998 | regulatory_filing_unaudited |
| Before | Expected total cost | about $110m | Dec 1998 | regulatory_filing_unaudited |
| Before | Net sales | $4,435.6m | 1998 | audited_filing |
| Before | Full-time employees | about 14,700 | Dec 1998 | regulatory_filing_unaudited |
| During | Order-to-cash go-live | 5 Jul 1999 (planned April) | 1999 | regulatory_filing_unaudited |
| During | Earnings warning | 8%-10% below expectations | 13 Sep 1999 | press_reported |
| During | Q3 net sales | $1,217.2m → $1,066.7m (−12%) | Q3 1998 → Q3 1999 | regulatory_filing_unaudited |
| During | Q3 gross margin | 42.0% → 40.6% | Q3 1999 | regulatory_filing_unaudited |
| During | Inventory build | +$120.6m (nine months) | Oct 1999 | regulatory_filing_unaudited |
| During | Distributor lead time | about 7 days → about 14 (worst about 45) | autumn 1999 | press_reported |
| After | Net sales | $3,970.9m | 1999 | audited_filing |
| After | Net income excluding pasta gain | down $45.6m (−13%) | 1999 | audited_filing |
| After | System spend to date / commitments | $98.8m + $13.2m / $115m-$120m | Dec 1999 | company_reported |
| After | Q3 profit | $87.6m → $107.4m (+23%) | Q3 1999 → Q3 2000 | press_reported |
- regulatory_filing_unaudited
- Text in an 8-K, 6-K or 10-Q, which is filed with a regulator but not audited.
- audited_filing
- A figure in audited financial statements, such as an annual report's financial statements or a 10-K.
- press_reported
- A journalist's own reporting.
- company_reported
- A company statement, press release or investor presentation that no one has independently checked.
Practices this case bears on
- SupportsGate every go-live on measured readiness, not on the calendar BP-001
- MixedWhen the thesis has failed, exit in one decisive move and say what is kept BP-007
- SupportsLimit how many things change at once, for the business and for the customer BP-012
- SupportsBudget the whole-life cost of a core programme, treat budget rises as new decisions, and retire legacy on a dated plan BP-013
- SupportsWhen a failure hits customers, tell them early, fix it completely, and compensate consistently BP-066
Sources
- S01 Hershey Foods Corporation Form 10-K for fiscal 1998 · Hershey Foods Corporation, Hershey Foods Corporation (SEC EDGAR), 1999-03 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S02 Hershey Foods Corporation Form 10-Q for the quarter ended 3 October 1999 · Hershey Foods Corporation, Hershey Foods Corporation (SEC EDGAR), 1999-11-12 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S03 Hershey Foods Corporation Form 10-K for fiscal 1999 · Hershey Foods Corporation, Hershey Foods Corporation (SEC EDGAR), 2000-03 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S04 Hershey Foods Corporation 1999 Annual Report financial section (Exhibit 13 to the fiscal 1999 Form 10-K) · Hershey Foods Corporation, Hershey Foods Corporation (SEC EDGAR), 2000-03 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S05 Hershey outlook turns sour · not stated, CNNfn (CNN Money), 1999-09-13 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S06 Computer a Halloween horror for Hershey · Associated Press, Deseret News (Associated Press), 1999-10-30 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S07 IT woes contribute to Hershey sales, profits decline · Craig Stedman, Computerworld, 2000-02-02 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S08 Halloween Less Haunting For Hershey This Year · Marc L. Songini, Computerworld, 2000-11-06 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S09 Halloween less spooky for Hershey's this year · not stated, Computerworld (ITworld staff), 2001-01-05 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S10 Hershey stays the course with mySAP.com upgrade · Todd Weiss, Computerworld, 2002-08-30 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S11 Supply Chain: Hershey's Bittersweet Lesson · Christopher Koch, CIO, 2002-11-15 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S12 ERP Implementation Failure at Hershey Foods Corporation (case ITSY059) · not stated, ICMR (IBS Center for Management Research), 2007 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S13 Halloween candy sales increased · Amity K. Moore, Supermarket News, 2000-02-14 · accessed 2026-10-31
- S14 Hershey Foods Corporation Form 10-K for fiscal 2000 · Hershey Foods Corporation, Hershey Foods Corporation (SEC EDGAR), 2001-03 · accessed 2026-10-31
Researched and fact-checked knowledgebase · Knowledgebase built 5 November 2026 · Last verified 1 November 2026
Practices, their evidence grades and case summaries are public. Full case studies are available in AXIOM to subscribers and AXIOM Discover participants.

