Skip to content

All best practices

CS-202failure

Hyflux Ltd (Singapore), a water-treatment and desalination company listed on the Singapore Exchange, through its subsidiary Tuaspring Pte Ltd

Tuaspring Integrated Water and Power Project: Singapore's largest desalination plant (318,500 m3/day) bid at S$0.45/m3 and paired with a 411 MW gas-fired power plant selling surplus electricity into the wholesale market (2011-2019), followed by court-supervised restructuring and liquidation

Region
Southeast Asia
Country
Singapore
Industry
Electric Power Utilities
Functions
Strategy, Corporate Development & Transformation Office, Treasury & Working Capital, Finance & FP&A, Risk, Compliance & Internal Audit, Operations & Service Delivery
Topics
Investment capital is not generating returns; Cash is trapped and liquidity is tightening; Energy, resource or climate exposure undermines economics; The business model is being disrupted
Starting situation
New initiative
Period
2011–2021
Last verified
5 November 2026

Executive summary

In 2011 Hyflux, Singapore's best-known water company, won the tender for the country's largest desalination plant with a tariff of 45 cents per cubic metre [C01, C04]. According to prosecutors at the 2025 trial, the price only worked because Tuaspring included a gas-fired power plant whose surplus electricity Hyflux would sell into the wholesale market, a business it had never run [C04]. On the same account, banks declined to lend on those terms, and Hyflux funded the project with its own loan and S$400m of preference shares sold largely to retail investors [C05, C06].

The desalination plant opened in 2013, but by the time the power plant sold commercially in 2016 wholesale prices had fallen by roughly three quarters [C09, C11]. Tuaspring lost S$114.5m in 2016 and S$81.9m in 2017, giving Hyflux its first annual loss [C13]. Divestment stalled, the company sought court protection in May 2018, booked a S$916.5m impairment, lost the plant to PUB for nothing in 2019 and was wound up in 2021 [C16, C17, C19, C23, C25].

Disclosure became a criminal matter: one former director pleaded guilty to failing to disclose Tuaspring information, and the former chief executive and others contested charges at trial [C26, C27, C28]. The lesson: a project whose economics rest on a market the company does not know needs to be tested, financed and disclosed as the risk it is.

Outcome: failure

The initiative was abandoned, exited or written down, or an official finding called it a failure.

Basis of the outcome

Hyflux's stated aim was to build, own and operate Tuaspring for 25 years, producing desalinated water for PUB at 45 cents per cubic metre while selling surplus power from the on-site plant to the national grid (S01, S11, S15). Four documented facts support the failure class. (1) The project lost money from its first commercial year: the 2017 annual report records Tuaspring losses of S$114.5m in 2016 and S$81.9m in 2017 and the group's first loss, attributed to the weak power market (S04). (2) It was written down: Hyflux booked a S$916.5m impairment, mainly on Tuaspring, in its results for January to September 2018 (S06). (3) It was lost: PUB served a default notice under the water purchase agreement, offered to take only the desalination plant for no payment while waiving compensation, and took it over in May 2019; the power plant was sold separately in 2022 (S09, S11, S15). (4) The company sought court protection in May 2018, entered judicial management in November 2020 and was wound up in July 2021 (S17, S07, S12). In addition, a former independent director pleaded guilty in 2025 to a charge of failing to disclose information relating to Tuaspring (S13); charges against the former chief executive and others were being contested at trial in the sources read (S05, S15).

Key figures

PhaseFigureValueWhenVerification
BeforeRevenueS$460.2m2011company_reported
BeforeFirst-year water tariffS$0.45 per m32011press_reported
BeforePreference shares raisedS$400mApr 2011multiple_independent
DuringTuaspring lossesS$114.5m and S$81.9m2016-2017company_reported
AfterImpairmentS$916.5mJan-Sep 2018press_reported
AfterRetail investors' holdings lostabout S$900m (about 34,000 holders)2018-2021multiple_independent
AfterFine on a former independent directorS$90,000Aug 2025press_reported
company_reported
A company statement, press release or investor presentation that no one has independently checked.
press_reported
A journalist's own reporting.
multiple_independent
Two or more independent sources agree.

Sources

  1. S01 Hyflux to produce world's cheapest desalinated water · not stated, Eco-Business (from The Business Times), 2011-07-06 · accessed 2026-11-05
  2. S02 Hyflux first quarter profit up 30% but Tuaspring power could incur losses · Tom Freyberg, WaterWorld, 2016-05-12 · accessed 2026-11-05
  3. S03 Hyflux Ltd Annual Report for FY2014 · Hyflux Ltd, Hyflux Ltd (filed on SGX), 2015 · accessed 2026-11-05
  4. S04 Hyflux Ltd Annual Report for FY2017 · Hyflux Ltd, Hyflux Ltd (filed on SGX), 2018 · accessed 2026-11-05
  5. S05 Singapore Hyflux trial opens as prosecutors detail Tuaspring risk omissions, S$900m investor losses · not stated, Malay Mail, 2025-08-11 · accessed 2026-11-05
  6. S06 Singapore seizes water plant from Hyflux after launching accounts probe · AFP, Free Malaysia Today (AFP), 2019-04-17 · accessed 2026-11-05
  7. S07 Singapore court orders embattled Hyflux into judicial management · Aradhana Aravindan, Yahoo Finance Singapore (Reuters), 2020-11-16 · accessed 2026-11-05
  8. S08 Former CEO, CFO and independent directors of Hyflux Ltd charged with offences under the Securities and Futures Act and the Companies Act · MAS, SPF and ACRA, Monetary Authority of Singapore (joint release with the Singapore Police Force and ACRA), 2022-11-17 · accessed 2026-11-05
  9. S09 Update on the reorganisation process: Tuaspring (announcement of 21 March 2019) · Hyflux Ltd, Hyflux Ltd (filed on SGX), 2019-03-21 · accessed 2026-11-05
  10. S10 PUB will take over Hyflux's Tuaspring Desalination Plant by May 17, 2019. How did we get here? · Matthias Ang, Mothership, 2019-04-19 · accessed 2026-11-05
  11. S11 Singapore may pay $0 for water plant that cost investors millions · David Yong, Bloomberg (via BloombergQuint), 2019-03 · accessed 2026-11-05
  12. S12 SGX announcement, 21 July 2021: liquidation · Liquidators of Hyflux Ltd, Hyflux Ltd (In Liquidation), filed on SGX, 2021-07-21 · accessed 2026-11-05
  13. S13 Indian-origin director of Singapore water company fined SGD 90,000 · PTI, The Tribune (PTI), 2025-08-08 · accessed 2026-11-05
  14. S14 Hyflux's Tuaspring bid undermined by financing shortfall · Eugene Mahalingam, The Star (Malaysia), from The Straits Times/ANN, 2025-09-04 · accessed 2026-11-05
  15. S15 Hyflux issued preference shares to fund Tuaspring as it had problems getting bank loans: Prosecution · not stated, The Star (Malaysia), 2025-08-11 · accessed 2026-11-05
  16. S16 Letter to shareholders (court-supervised reorganisation) · Olivia Lum, Executive Chairman and Group CEO, Hyflux Ltd (filed on SGX), 2018-05 · accessed 2026-11-05
  17. S17 Fallen Singapore high-flyer gets court protection to reorganise · Bloomberg News, Malay Mail (Bloomberg), 2018-05-23 · accessed 2026-11-05

Researched and fact-checked knowledgebase · Knowledgebase built 5 November 2026 · Last verified 5 November 2026

Practices, their evidence grades and case summaries are public. Full case studies are available in AXIOM to subscribers and AXIOM Discover participants.