BP-019Grade B27 supporting cases (26 counted), 0 counter-examples
Treat vendor attestations, awards and executive testimony as claims to test, not as assurance
The practice
Require independent evidence (your own testing, independent reviews, published impact studies) before relying on a supplier's attestation, an award or the testimony of the people who led the change.
Why it works
The people closest to a change, and the vendors paid to deliver it, have an interest in reporting success, and awards often reward announcements rather than outcomes. An assurance report covers only what it tested, and boards rarely hear what it did not. Independent measurement, whether a separate test of a provider's capacity, a commissioned impact study or an outside monitor, breaks the link between the claim and the claimant. It also protects the company when results are later questioned. Before copying a celebrated model, the same test applies: ask for evidence of its effect that does not come from its promoters.
KB synthesis: the mechanism is the knowledgebase's own reasoning, drawn from the member lessons. Factual support is the case claims under evidence.cases and the research under evidence.research (R-refs).
How to apply it
- Test critical supplier capacity yourself; do not accept an attestation as a substitute.
- Require every assurance report to state what it did not test, and tell the board.
- Have performance claims tested by someone other than the people who make them.
- Commission and publish independent impact evidence for flagship programmes.
- Judge programmes on stable, disclosed metrics rather than awards or vendor case studies.
Warning signs
- The main evidence of success is an industry award or a vendor press release.
- Assurance scope is not reported alongside its conclusion.
- The same team designs, delivers and evaluates the change.
When it applies
- Outsourced delivery, regulatory remediation, operating-model change and copied management models.
When it does not
- Low-stakes changes where the cost of independent testing exceeds the risk.
Evidence grade: Grade B
At least 6 counted supporting cases for every 100 cases in the knowledgebase (6 × cases ÷ 100, rounded to the nearest whole number), whose primary regions span at least 4 regions.
Why this grade
Grade B by schema 4.10 route: >=14 counted cases across >=4 primary regions (the case bar is 6 per 100 cases in the knowledgebase, 235 cases). A needs a systematic, peer-reviewed study that tests this practice. None of the research cited in the KB does. 1 supporting case(s) rest only on company-reported claims and are not counted toward the grade.
Where it applies
- Transformation type
- Topic (business problem)
- Function
- Starting situation
- Industry
- Region
Supporting and counter cases
Emirates NBD CS-015
ING Group (ING Netherlands) CS-012
Volkswagen AG CS-080
Safaricom (with Vodafone) CS-014
Haggen, Inc. (Haggen Food & Pharmacy), owned by the private-equity firm Comvest CS-101
County of Marin, California CS-105
Waste Management, Inc. CS-107
Slater and Gordon Limited CS-109
Satyam Computer Services (Mahindra Satyam), acquired by Tech Mahindra CS-118
Researched and fact-checked knowledgebase · Knowledgebase built 5 November 2026
Practices, their evidence grades and case summaries are public. Full case studies are available in AXIOM to subscribers and AXIOM Discover participants.

