CS-206failure
South African Revenue Service (SARS), the national tax and customs administration of South Africa, advised by Bain & Company South Africa
The 2014-2018 restructuring of SARS under Commissioner Tom Moyane: a new operating model designed with Bain & Company that broke up the Large Business Centre and specialist enforcement units, later found by two judicial commissions to be a massive failure of governance and reversed from 2018
- Region
- Africa
- Country
- South Africa
- Industry
- Public Sector and Government (Other (cross-industry))
- Functions
- Strategy, Corporate Development & Transformation Office, HR & Workforce, Risk, Compliance & Internal Audit, Operations & Service Delivery, Procurement & Strategic Sourcing
- Topics
- Bureaucracy and slow decisions prevent agility; Critical skills are missing or becoming obsolete; Regulatory complexity is overwhelming controls; Cross-functional processes are slow and broken; Competing transformation programs overwhelm resources
- Starting situation
- New initiative
- Period
- 2014–2018
- Last verified
- 5 November 2026
Executive summary
In 2014 South Africa's revenue service, regarded internationally as one of the better tax administrations and collecting close to R1 trillion a year with more than 14,000 staff, began a restructuring under a new commissioner, Tom Moyane, designed with the consultancy Bain & Company [C01, C20]. Bain was hired through a closed tender for a small diagnostic and then extended by deviation into a 27-month engagement worth about R164m [C02, C03, C23].
The new operating model folded corporate and individual tax into one division reporting to the commissioner and broke up the Large Business Centre and several enforcement units [C05, C07]. A judicial commission later found that about 200 managers were displaced, skilled staff left, litigation and customs slowed, and that the whole episode was 'a massive failure of integrity and governance' [C06, C07, C08, C09].
The restructuring was then reversed: the commissioner was dismissed in November 2018, the large-business and illicit-economy units were brought back, and the adviser repaid its fees and was barred from public contracts in South Africa for ten years [C14, C16, C17, C25]. For any organisation, the case shows how a restructuring that is designed before a diagnosis, procured outside normal rules and run without independent challenge can dismantle the capabilities it was meant to strengthen.
Outcome: failure
The initiative was abandoned, exited or written down, or an official finding called it a failure.
Basis of the outcome
The restructuring was presented as a new operating model for SARS, designed with Bain & Company after a procurement that began with a closed tender in December 2014 and was extended by deviation (S01). Three documented facts support the failure class. (1) Official findings: the Nugent Commission found a massive failure of integrity and governance at SARS, that the Large Business Centre had been eviscerated, that about 200 managers were displaced and skilled staff left, and that enforcement, litigation and customs capacity deteriorated (S01); the Zondo Commission accepted those findings, found that Bain and the incoming commissioner planned the restructuring before his appointment, and called the extensions an unlawful use of procurement deviations (S07, S08). (2) Reversal: the commissioner was dismissed in November 2018 (S02, S15), SARS decided in August 2018 to bring back the Large Business Unit and the Illicit Economy Team (S13) and relaunched the Large Business Centre in October 2019 (S04). (3) The adviser repaid its fees with interest and was restricted from South African public contracts for ten years from September 2022 (S01, S14). Revenue in 2017/18 fell R48.2bn short of the estimate; the National Treasury could not fully explain the drop and the former commissioner blamed the economy (S12).
Key figures
| Phase | Figure | Value | When | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before | Tax revenue collected | R986.4bn | 2014/15 | official_statement |
| Before | SARS staff | over 14,000 | 2015 | official_statement |
| During | Bain fee for the restructuring phase | about R164m | 2015-2017 | official_finding |
| During | Managers displaced | about 200 | 2015-2018 | official_finding |
| During | Revenue shortfall against estimate | R48.2bn | 2017/18 | press_reported |
| After | Bain's repayment including interest | just short of R217m | Dec 2018 | official_finding |
| After | Restriction on Bain in South Africa | 10 years (2022-2032) | Sep 2022 | press_reported |
| After | Net revenue, 2021/22 | R1.563tn | Apr 2022 | official_statement |
- official_statement
- A government or ministerial statement. It is official, but political, and is not a finding.
- official_finding
- A finding of an inquiry, court or regulator.
- press_reported
- A journalist's own reporting.
Practices this case bears on
- SupportsMake line managers and the front line own the change, and train users before they get access BP-009
- SupportsOutsource only what does not differentiate, and keep the capability to specify, integrate and replace partners BP-017
- SupportsTreat vendor attestations, awards and executive testimony as claims to test, not as assurance BP-019
- SupportsMake bad news safe and fast to reach the top, and act on it BP-022
- SupportsBuild independent challenge into the board for transformational bets BP-024
- SupportsAfter a control or conduct failure, fix governance, leadership and incentives before strategy, and keep individual accountability proportionate and separate BP-025
- SupportsInvestigate failures independently at full scale, let outsiders validate the fix, and turn the findings into permanent checks BP-026
- SupportsReorganise around the new business and the units that face customers, before the transition, not after BP-030
- SupportsSeparate the programme's own effect from tailwinds, shocks and one-off gains before claiming credit BP-035
- SupportsWrite exit and pause criteria at approval, and treat impairments as triggers to re-test the strategy BP-042
- SupportsRe-plan openly when the facts change, rather than defending the old timetable BP-043
- SupportsProtect the integrity of procurement and appointments, and test feasibility before signing long contracts BP-068
- SupportsDiagnose the root cause and the gap to the best before choosing the remedy BP-069
- SupportsWhen the value walks out of the door, protect clients and key people before restructuring anything else BP-074
Sources
- S01 Commission of Inquiry into Tax Administration and Governance by SARS: Final Report · Judge R. W. Nugent (chair), The Presidency, Republic of South Africa, 2018-12-11 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S02 Moyane fired as SARS commissioner · not stated, SAnews (South African Government News Agency), 2018-11-02 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S03 Bain banned from UK govt contracts over role in SARS capture · not stated, Polity (Creamer Media), 2022-08-03 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S04 SARS launches re-established Large Business Centre · not stated, Bizcommunity (from SAnews.gov.za), 2019-10-24 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S05 Highly-specialised SARS unit left 'stripped and fragmented' under Moyane · Amil Umraw, TimesLIVE, 2018-08-27 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S06 5 key takeaways from Bain's statement on SARS · not stated, Fin24 (News24), 2018-12-18 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S07 Five things to know about the State Capture Commission's findings and recommendations on SARS · Pauli van Wyk, Daily Maverick, 2022-01-04 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S08 Judicial Commission of Inquiry into State Capture, Report Part 1, chapter on SARS and Bain & Company · Chief Justice R. M. M. Zondo (chair), Judicial Commission of Inquiry into State Capture, 2022-01-04 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S09 Bain hits back at scathing Zondo report · not stated, Polity (Creamer Media), 2022-01-07 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S10 State Capture report: How Bain & Company nearly collapsed Sars · Amanda Watson, The Citizen, 2022-01-06 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S11 Preliminary outcomes of revenue collection for the 2014/2015 fiscal year · SARS, South African Revenue Service, 2015-04-01 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S12 Sars shortfall to blame for VAT hike - Treasury · Tehillah Nieselow, Mail & Guardian, 2018-08-29 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S13 Sars to re-establish Large Business Unit, Illicit Economy Team · not stated, Engineering News (Creamer Media), 2018-08-27 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S14 Treasury bans Bain & Co. from public sector contracts for a decade · not stated, Engineering News (Creamer Media), 2022-09-29 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S15 Moyane fired over 'deeply concerning' state of SARS - Ramaphosa · not stated, Fin24 (News24), 2018-11-01 · accessed 2026-11-05
- S16 Speaking notes: Commissioner's revenue announcement, 1 April 2022 · Edward Kieswetter, South African Revenue Service, 2022-04-01 · accessed 2026-11-05
Researched and fact-checked knowledgebase · Knowledgebase built 5 November 2026 · Last verified 5 November 2026
Practices, their evidence grades and case summaries are public. Full case studies are available in AXIOM to subscribers and AXIOM Discover participants.

