CS-105failure
County of Marin, California
SAP ERP implemented with Deloitte Consulting (agreement 2005, live 2006), abandoned in 2010, litigated, and replaced by the ATOM programme on Tyler Munis (2014-2021)
- Region
- North America
- Country
- United States
- Industry
- Public Sector and Government (Other (cross-industry))
- Functions
- Finance & FP&A, HR & Workforce, IT, ERP & Digital, Procurement & Strategic Sourcing, Risk, Compliance & Internal Audit
- Topics
- Legacy ERP and fragmented systems block execution; Technology spending is growing without business returns; Data cannot be trusted for critical decisions; Cross-functional processes are slow and broken
- Starting situation
- In-flight initiative
- Period
- 2005–2021
- Last verified
- 4 November 2026
Executive summary
Marin County, a California county of about 258,000 people, contracted Deloitte in 2005 to implement SAP for finance, payroll and HR, and went live in 2006 [C01, C06]. By 2010 its own assessment found only half of mandatory functions working in SAP and no basic financial reports [C02].
Comparing ten-year costs, the county chose to replace rather than fix the system (US$26.2m against US$49.8m) and sued Deloitte and SAP; it settled for US$3.9m after about US$5m in legal fees, having spent at least US$30m on the project [C03, C05, C06].
Two civil grand juries later reviewed the project. They found it launched with too much, too fast and too few resources, that the finance module failed at go-live in 2006 and payroll in 2007, and that no single action or person explained the failure [C12, C15, C16].
Its second attempt, a not-to-exceed US$8.2m contract for a government-specific system, put finance live on time in 2016 and payroll more than three years late, fully live in 2021 [C08, C09, C11]. The lesson: size the product and the contract to the organisation, and keep the option to stop.
Outcome: failure
The initiative was abandoned, exited or written down, or an official finding called it a failure.
Basis of the outcome
In 2010 the county's own assessment found the SAP system met about half of its mandatory functions and did not produce basic financial reports, and county officials, reporting to the Board of Supervisors, said they would replace it rather than fix it (S01, S02). The county sued Deloitte and SAP, spent about US$5m on litigation and settled for US$3.9m (S03, S05). The system was replaced by a new ERP that went fully live in 2021 (S05, S06). Abandonment of the system meets the failure criterion; the replacement is recorded as a separate, later programme.
Key figures
| Phase | Figure | Value | When | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before | SAP licence | US$2.23m | 2005 | press_reported |
| Before | Deloitte fees for installation | US$8.8m | 2005-2009 | press_reported |
| During | Mandatory functions met in SAP | 50% | 2010 | official_statement |
| During | SAP support staff | 23 FTE | 2010 | official_statement |
| During | Positions cut in prior 3 years | 180 | 2010 | official_statement |
| After | Total spent on SAP project | at least US$30m | 2013 | press_reported |
| After | Settlement / legal fees | US$3.9m / about US$5m | 2013 | press_reported |
| After | Replacement contract cap | US$8,171,357 | Dec 2014 | official_statement |
| After | Employees on new system | more than 2,000 | 2021 | company_reported |
| During | Extra Deloitte add-on billing | US$2.6m | 2007 | official_finding |
| After | Total project cost estimates | US$23.7m to US$34.7m | 2013 | official_finding |
| After | Damages sought in second suit | US$90m | Dec 2010 | official_finding |
- press_reported
- A journalist's own reporting.
- official_statement
- A government or ministerial statement. It is official, but political, and is not a finding.
- company_reported
- A company statement, press release or investor presentation that no one has independently checked.
- official_finding
- A finding of an inquiry, court or regulator.
Practices this case bears on
- SupportsGate every go-live on measured readiness, not on the calendar BP-001
- SupportsDecide what truly differentiates before buying standard software; change the process for everything else BP-002
- SupportsRoll out operational and system change in waves, each proven before the next BP-006
- SupportsWhen the thesis has failed, exit in one decisive move and say what is kept BP-007
- SupportsBudget the whole-life cost of a core programme, treat budget rises as new decisions, and retire legacy on a dated plan BP-013
- SupportsMake a business executive, not IT, the owner of a technology-led transformation BP-015
- SupportsOutsource only what does not differentiate, and keep the capability to specify, integrate and replace partners BP-017
- SupportsSecure the scarce delivery skills early, and build the pipeline in-house when the market cannot supply it BP-018
- SupportsTreat vendor attestations, awards and executive testimony as claims to test, not as assurance BP-019
- SupportsMake bad news safe and fast to reach the top, and act on it BP-022
- SupportsBuild independent challenge into the board for transformational bets BP-024
- SupportsScale risk, quality and control functions with the speed and size of the change BP-027
- SupportsWrite exit and pause criteria at approval, and treat impairments as triggers to re-test the strategy BP-042
- SupportsDecide what litigation or a dispute is for, and settle against its full cost and duration BP-067
- SupportsProtect the integrity of procurement and appointments, and test feasibility before signing long contracts BP-068
Sources
- S01 County of Marin SAP system assessment and options report · County of Marin, County of Marin, Information Systems & Technology, 2010-07-26 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S02 California county dumps SAP · Kathleen Hickey, Route Fifty (GCN), 2010-08-25 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S03 Marin County seeks new software vendor to replace SAP system · Chris Kanaracus, Computerworld (IDG News Service), 2013-11-01 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S04 County Green Lights $14 Million Software Agreement · Renee Schiavone, Patch, 2014-12-12 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S05 Marin County Admin Solution to Fully Deploy · not stated, Techwire (Marin Independent Journal via Tribune Content Agency), 2020 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S06 Marin County, California, Goes Live on Integrated ERP Solution from Tyler Technologies · Tyler Technologies, Tyler Technologies, 2021-03-23 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S07 Marin's Software Saga Continues - But Is There MERIT In ATOM? · 2012-2013 Marin County Civil Grand Jury, Marin County Civil Grand Jury, 2013-06-05 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S08 Marin County computer mistakes could have been averted, report says · Richard Halstead, Marin Independent Journal (reposted by California Grand Jury News), 2009-06-22 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S09 Deloitte hit with $30M lawsuit over failed ERP project · Jaikumar Vijayan, Computerworld, 2010-06-04 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S10 Marin County Accuses Deloitte of, Among Other Things, Using 'Neophytes' on SAP Project · Caleb Newquist, Going Concern, 2010-06-03 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S11 Marin Sues Deloitte Over SAP System · Rebecca Beyer, Daily Journal, 2010-06-02 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S12 SAP's 'Ramp-Up' program fingered in ERP lawsuit · Chris Kanaracus, Network World (IDG News Service), 2011-05-26 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S13 Deloitte wants software lawsuit kept away from jury · Chris Kanaracus, Computerworld (IDG News Service), 2011-07-05 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S14 County of Marin v. Deloitte Consulting LLP et al., No. C 11-00381 SI, order on motions to dismiss · Judge Susan Illston, Justia (US District Court, Northern District of California), 2011-12-27 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S15 Judge Tosses Racketeering Claims in Marin County Lawsuit Against SAP · Chris Kanaracus, PCWorld (IDG News Service), 2011-12-28 · accessed 2026-11-04
- S16 Judge dismisses one Marin County suit versus Deloitte · Jaikumar Vijayan, Computerworld, 2012-04-12 · accessed 2026-11-04
Researched and fact-checked knowledgebase · Knowledgebase built 5 November 2026 · Last verified 4 November 2026
Practices, their evidence grades and case summaries are public. Full case studies are available in AXIOM to subscribers and AXIOM Discover participants.

