Skip to content
Enterprise Architecture — one company, five architectures, one decision system: ESA, ETA, ECA, EPA and ERRA on one enterprise state, unified as UETA and optimized through GEOP

Enterprise Architecture

One company, five descriptions.

DCT describes a company in five ways: its wiring, its moves, its capital, its performance and its exposure. Then it insists that the five describe one company. The architectures stand on one skeleton and read one state, a register records what passes between them, and the decision problem sits on top of all five.

EPAVol I, Ch 11AP

Enterprise Performance Architecture (EPA)

What does it deliver?

What it is

The Enterprise Performance Architecture is what the company delivers each period, kept apart from what it has (Vol I, Ch 11). Performance is a flow, produced from the state and the period's decisions (Def 11.1); capital is a stock. The book names ten dimensions: financial, operational, strategic, human, technological, innovation, governance, environmental, resilience and sustainability performance (Def 11.3, Table 11.2).

The architecture has three parts (Def 11.2). Each dimension has supports, the components where it is produced. Measurement maps turn a dimension into indicators and metrics, and an indicator is an estimate, with an error model and a range where it is valid, not the thing it estimates (Defs 11.5–11.6). The third part is the apparatus that turns many readings into one verdict: weights, normalizations, the aggregation rule, target cascades and the governance that owns them.

The aggregation rule decides how far strength may excuse weakness (Table 11.3). A weighted average lets any strength make up for any weakness; a geometric mean allows less; the minimum allows none; a floor rule ranks on the first tier and uses the next only to break ties. Sustainable performance is performance that could continue while every stock receives its rent (Def 11.11).

Who ranks first is a choice of weights (seed 26111)
Ch. I.11 Who ranks first is a choice of weights (seed 26111)

The board questions it answers

  • Did the data choose this option, or did the scorecard's design?
  • How close are our weights to a tie, and does changing the yardstick reverse the ranking?
  • How long must we wait before judging a transformation fairly?
  • Are we on the frontier, and what does a point of one dimension cost in another?
  • Every division improved its margin; did the group?
  • Is this year's performance sustainable, or borrowed from a stock?

What the book proves

  • Prop 11.1 No single financial measure is complete.
  • Thm 11.1(iii) An indicator that merges levels the company would rank differently loses information before anyone games it.
  • Thm 11.2 Between non-dominated options the weights decide. Normalization is a second set of weights, and the aggregation rule sets how much compensation is allowed.
  • Thm 11.3(iii) A programme that builds the state traces a J-curve: its costs land at once and its gains arrive through the business, so the shortest fair review window is one period plus the dip divided by the gain.
  • Thm 11.4 The frontier exists and its slope is an exchange rate between dimensions; weighting reaches it but can miss balanced options that cannot be split.
  • Thm 11.5 Ratios do not average: every unit can improve its margin while the group's falls, and every roll-up needs a certificate.

Meridian, the book’s worked company

Meridian's CFO scorecard is the book's running example of a performance apparatus.

  • The scorecard is a quarter of (liquidity index + technology + efficiency − strategic risk); today it reads 37.0. (Vol I, WE 1.1; WE 11.1)
  • At Year 5, at equal weights, the three options score 47.08 (digital build), 46.07 (restructuring) and 38.40 (turnaround). None dominates: digital leads on technology by 36.8 points, restructuring on liquidity, on risk and, narrowly, on efficiency. (Vol I, Table 1.9; OA 11.B.Ex.6)
  • Each point of weight moved from technology to liquidity cuts digital's lead by 0.64, so the lead is gone after 1.6 points, at 26.6% liquidity and 23.4% technology. At 2 points, restructuring leads 47.7 to 47.5. (Vol I, WE 11.1 Step 2; Fig 11.1)
  • Change only the scaling and the ranking moves: with best = 100 and worst = 0 restructuring comes first (52.3); with percentage improvement digital comes first (24.0). (Vol I, WE 11.1 Step 3; Table 11.6)
  • The J-curve: digital's score falls to 32.11 at month 11 and is back above 37.0 at month 29. Annual reviews rank it last in Years 1 and 2; only a five-year window ranks it first. (Vol I, WE 11.1 Step 4; OA 11.B.Ex.6)
  • Supports: financial and resilience performance at treasury, operational at Industrial Systems and Materials, strategic at the three divisions, technological at Digital, innovation at Digital and engineering. Nothing done in Digital can reach Industrial Systems' operations in under two quarters, and no path leads from Digital to Materials at all. (Vol I, Table 11.4)

Explore it

Dimensions, readings, weights

The ten dimensions of Vol I, Table 11.2, and how Meridian's CFO scorecard turns four readings into one verdict on three options (WE 11.1). Select a node to read what it is and the book's numbers.

DimensionsTable 11.2Scorecard readingsYear 5Weightsthe apparatusVerdictequal weightsFinancialPF​OperationalPO​StrategicPS​HumanPH​TechnologicalPT​InnovationPI​GovernancePG​EnvironmentalPE​ResiliencePR​SustainabilityPESG​Liquidity indexweight ¼Technologyweight ¼Efficiencyweight ¼Strategic riskweight −¼CFO scorecard¼(L + T + E − R)Digital build47.08Restructuring46.07Turnaround38.40

Dimensions

The CFO scorecard

Who wins depends on the weights

The Year-5 readings of Vol I, Table 1.9, scored with the CFO's formula. Move weight between technology and liquidity: at equal weights the scores are the book's 47.08, 46.07 and 38.40, and the lead changes hands where the book says it does.

Weights: Liquidity 25.0%, Technology 25.0%, Efficiency 25.0%, Strategic risk −25.0%

203040506070-20-100+10+20Digital buildRestructuringTurnaround
  1. Digital build: 47.08 · first
  2. Restructuring: 46.07
  3. Turnaround: 38.40

Vol I, WE 11.1; Table 1.9; Fig 11.1. At equal weights: 47.08, 46.07, 38.40; the lead changes hands after 1.6 points (26.6% liquidity, 23.4% technology); at 2 points restructuring leads 47.7 to 47.5.

How it goes wrong

  • The weights decide between options that no data separates, and the verdict is presented as the data's (Thm 11.2).
  • The scale is changed and the ranking reverses with no new information (Table 11.6).
  • A programme is reviewed inside its dip and stopped before its gains arrive (Thm 11.3).
  • Credit is claimed for an improvement the wiring cannot carry, such as Materials' efficiency for the digital programme (§11.6).
  • Ratios are averaged across units, and the group looks better, or worse, than it is (Thm 11.5).
  • A year's performance is borrowed from a stock by skipping its rent (Def 11.11).

What a company must declare

  • For each objective and measure: the dimension it belongs to and its support components.
  • Each indicator's error band, direction, normalization and reference group.
  • The scorecard apparatus: weights declared by the board, the aggregation rule, any floor rules, and the review window for each programme.
  • For ratio measures, the numerator and denominator by unit.
  • The options to be scored, with their readings at the horizon.

How AXIOM uses it

AXIOM computes each objective's chance of reaching its target, and ranks by a stated floor rule unless the board declares weights; it never supplies weights of its own. Tie distances, normalization checks and the J-curve review window belong to AXIOM's architecture module (in development).

Best Practices

Practices from the Corporate Transformation Best Practices knowledgebase that bear on this architecture.

Cases

Further reading

Read it on the DCT MapIn the LexiconRead the chapter: Vol I, Ch 11

Where to go next